How to Stop Overthinking Without Fighting Yourself
Updated: Oct 2
Written and clinically reviewed by Stephanie Post, PsyD
It’s 11pm and you’re running the conversation again. The one from this afternoon.
You’ve already worked out what you should have said. Now you’re working out what you’ll say if it comes up again and what you’ll do if it doesn’t.
You know this isn’t helping. You’ve told yourself so. You’ve probably told yourself a lot of things;
that you’re overreacting, that it will be fine, that you should let it go.
And here you still are.
The problem may not be that you haven’t tried hard enough to stop overthinking. It may be that stopping isn’t the move.
Why “you’ll be fine” backfires
When a worried thought shows up, most of us reach for the same tool: we argue with it.
It’s not that bad. You’re being dramatic. Even if it goes wrong, you’ll figure it out.
Sometimes that works. Often it doesn’t and for some people it backfires.
In a study published in Psychological Science, researchers asked people to repeat the phrase “I am a lovable person” to themselves.
Participants who already felt good about themselves felt slightly better afterwards. Participants with low self-esteem (the people the phrase was meant to help) felt worse than those who said nothing at all.
The researchers ran a second experiment that’s even more interesting.
This time, one group was told to focus only on ways the statement was true. Another group was told to consider ways it might be true and ways it might not be.
For people with low self-esteem, the second group came out better.
Being allowed to hold both was more settling than being pushed towards the positive.
This finding matches something I see often in my practice:
You don’t stop overthinking by trying to stop it. You stop overthinking by helping the part of you that’s afraid feel supported.
You offer that part something it’s never had before: unconditional support in the moment it’s activated.
I use the word “parts” deliberately. When the overthinking part of you is running things, it isn’t all of you even though it can feel that way.
In my work, I teach a simple nervous-system-based framework called The N3 Method
The N3 Method: Notice, Name, Nurture
1. Notice
Notice what’s happening in your thoughts, body and tone.
For example you might notice you’re replaying the conversation you had in your mind and there’s tension across your shoulders.
2. Name
Name the part that's taken the wheel.
If it’s spiraling thoughts, call it the Overthinker. If what you’re feeling is worry, call it the Worrier. If it’s harsh self-judgement, call it the Critic.
Use whatever name actually fits what you’re noticing.
Putting feelings into words has been shown to reduce distress. In a study published in Emotion, before labeling their feelings, participants predicted they’d end up more distressed, not less. They were wrong. Putting their feelings into words actually made them calmer.
However, the calming effect tends to show up later rather than immediately and can briefly intensify things first. If that happens to you, it’s not a sign you’ve done it wrong.
3. Nurture
This is the step people skip and it’s the one where things actually start to shift.
Rather than arguing with the Overthinker or (whichever part is active) and trying to make it go away, you offer it acceptance with no conditions attached. You soothe it.
This is where the I Love You Anyway tapping comes in.
How to do the I Love You Anyway Tapping
1. Get settled. Sit somewhere you won’t be interrupted.
2. Start tapping, alternating sides.
Left, right, left, right, on your shoulders, knees or thighs. Whichever is comfortable.
Keep it slow and steady.
3. Speak to the part that’s activated out loud.
Use its own overthinking, worry, criticism, then add the acceptance. It sounds like this:
“I know you’re feeling like you’re not good enough, and I love you anyway” “I know you’re scared you’ll be exposed or judged, and I accept you anyway” “I know you’re full of self-doubt right now, and I support you anyway”
Nothing is being fixed. Nothing is being convinced.
Instead, while tapping, you’re doing three powerful things at once:
1. Talking aloud to the part, rather than about it
2. Acknowledging the experience it’s having; the emotions, sensations and beliefs
3. Offering unconditionality (love, acceptance or support) without requiring it to change
This matters because the overthinker isn’t looking for reassurance that “everything will be fine”
It’s looking for confirmation that:
I’m not alone with this. I don’t have to be perfect to be held. I can soften without danger.
Positive thinking often backfires because it bypasses the part that’s afraid.
The I Love You Anyway tapping works because it:
Welcomes all parts
Keeps you present in your body
Offers relational safety instead of pressure
Allows the overthinker to relax instead of bracing for a fight
Protective parts don’t soften through logic, they soften through relationship.
4. Keep going with whatever comes next.
New thought, a new feeling, a sensation somewhere in your body.
Address each one the same way, out loud, still tapping.
5. Watch for the wordiness.
You start out simply “I know you’re worried, and I love you anyway” and then you veer off script and get wordier
“I know you feel worried about the job, but even if you don’t get it, it’s their loss. You’ll find something better.”
That sounds supportive. It's also an argument. You’ve gone back to trying to convince the overthinker to stop overthinking.
Go back to soothing it instead.
6. Stop when something softens.
You’ll feel it start to settle, you’ll get a little more room to breathe and maybe an exhale that arrives on its own.
If you're overthinking, there's nothing wrong with you. That part has simply been working too hard, for too long, without support.
Learning to work with an overthinking mind through parts work therapy and practices like the I Love You Anyway tapping isn't about thinking less or caring less.
It's about becoming supported.
And from that place, your thoughts get quieter.
Stephanie Post, PsyD. is a trauma-informed somatic psychologist based in the San Francisco Bay Area. She integrates EMDR, Sensorimotor Psychotherapy, and Internal Family Systems to help adults overcome trauma, anxiety, low self-esteem, and depression, and to live more authentic, embodied lives. Reach out to her here.
Related: [EMDR Therapy] . [Internal Family Systems] . [Somatic Therapy] . [Anxiety Treatment] .
References
Comments